The Crime of Intangibility

Last year, the US music industry saw its largest spike in recorded music revenue in nearly two decades, driven by a surge in online song streaming. It was a remarkable reversal from just 10 years ago, when the online distribution of songs threatened to crush the industry. But this change in fortunes, as Mark Mayhey discusses, has created a new set of winners and losers across the globe.
Putting aside the debate on the lifespan of albums, clearly musicians today can harness the power of the internet to their albums' advantage. But the shift to streaming has worked out well for musicians at the top - the Drakes and Rihannas of the world. It threatens almost everyone else hoping to earn enough money to sustain a musicmaking career. With streaming's emphasis on individual songs and algorithms that reinforce already popular choices, the hitmaker's reward is skewed as never before.
Today, less than 1 percent of songs represent 86 percent of the music streamed, according to the market research company Nielsen. It wasn't supposed to turn out like this. A decade ago, industry insiders talked of digital distribution's "long tail", where any musician could be discovered through the sharing power of the Web, even if they didn't make it to the top of the charts or record companies ignored them. Now that's changed. The rich are getting richer.
Even in an industry long centered on superstars, the result of these shifts is a growing sense that musicians need to go viral right away or risk oblivion. Musicians have less time to hone their skills and develop their sound. This worries industry observers who see a new economic model that makes it tougher for new acts to survive. In Turkey, music label DMC has tried to respond to this criticism by creating Ev Yapımı Müzik ("home produced music") - a portal where unsigned artists can upload from their bedrooms, get heard and possibly get a single released under a DMC ticket.
Although it's easier to get in the game, it's harder to win. The problem for artists is the abundance of choices that listeners have. No one can keep up. Spotify alone adds about 15,000 new songs each week. Anyone can post a new song to sites such as Bandcamp or SoundCloud. With so much competition, musical acts are quickly forgotten unless they surge to the top.The old gatekeepers - radio and record labels - were far from perfect. Labels pushed only a limited number of artists. Radio had only so many hours of airtime. That limited the amount of music that people were exposed to, making music a relatively scarce commodity. This gave some acts time to grow. It was not a perfect system, but it had certain advantages compared with today.
Their privatisation in Turkey lit the fuse that allowed the Turkish pop explosion of the nineties - Turkey's first MTV-style broadcaster Kral created an environment that allowed the music video to flourish. That brought Kral's MVAs and the crowning of Tarkan as their prince of pop, and the money came rolling in. The American model of commercial entourages sprang up. Music managers and middle men emerged. Labels began to expand. Artist signings and transfers went for millions.
But with economic success came the invisible parasite of chart manipulation. And when digitisation kicked down the industry's door, with only ten years under its belt, it wasn't able to free itself from its small independent status. Huge revenue losses followed, and producers were less willing to invest, record labels unwilling to throw money at new acts. Their stranglehold tightened. Creativity choked.
Now that music is superabundant again, the business (beyond selling subscriptions to music sites) thrives only where scarcity can be manufactured - in open air arenas and beach clubs, where there are only so many seats, or in advertising, where one song or band can anchor a branding campaign. Such money has made music gimmicky, sometimes criminally so.
Fifteen years ago, more than half of an artist's revenue came from selling music, on average, according to MIDIA Research. Today, that has fallen to one-third. Only about 20 percent of an artist's income comes from selling music. That's the same amount flowing from sync deals, a sign of the rising importance of selling songs to advertisers and filmmakers.
The Turkish music industry's lifeline at the moment is its TV industry, but its musicians today earn over half their income from concert sales. There is a summer circuit and a winter circuit of shows. Streaming plays a pivotal role in all of this - it's often the performance on streaming services driving whether musicians get booked and how much they get paid. Albums might be on the way out, but streaming favours superstar acts in a way physical albums do not: If you get into a listener's playlist, you can get into their head.
Streaming is a Serial Killer
Things have changed on a deep level. The economics of the music industry are evolving. In the US three years ago, music acts still toured mainly to boost CD sales and digital downloads at a time when people were still buying music, despite music sales already having collapsed from their 1999 peak. Apple's iTunes remained popular. Streaming services were unproven and just picking up steam, contributing not even half of the revenue that still came from CDs, vinyl and digital downloads.
Then, thanks to the explosion of ever-better smartphones and big bets by big technology companies and upstarts, streaming took off. A new business model emerged. People today consume more music than ever, but are spending less thanks to streaming services that have put seemingly every track just one click away for a price that's close to free. In the UK, streaming has rocketed 500% since 2013, with 45bn audio streams over 2016. A mind-boggling 1.2bn songs a day were streamed last year in the US, according to BuzzAngle Music.
Music fans can choose from a range of streaming services that allow people to listen to songs while not owning the music. The services pay fractions of a penny each time a song is played, supported by ads or monthly subscriptions. Last year, that added up to just under $4bn of the $7.7bn in US music revenue. But as much as streaming has grown, its failure to make up for a general loss of revenue in music is noticeable.
Although as an industry music still generates more than film revenue, the number of sales are down overall by mentionable margins. In the first half of 2014, Americans purchased 593.6m digital tracks and heard 70.3m video and audio streams for a sum total of 663.9m. In the comparable period of 2013, the total came to 731.7m. And analysts say the clock is ticking for Spotify, as it plans to go public, over the brutal arithmetic of keeping costs low but paying out more to artists. If Spotify can't do the math, it may fail to be economically viable in the future.
There is no denying that Spotify and the rest have changed the musical landscape. These services were a response to the early-2000s explosion in digital music piracy - in turn embraced possibly in part to the growing cynicism against major record labels and chart manipulation. Initially an open unregulated arena, once the cyber stream was diverted to the mainstream, no one talked about album sales anymore.
The success of streaming brought focus on boosting an act's presence on social media and Spotify and its counterparts. Getting your numbers up in the virtual aisle of easy listening is what it's all about; the focus is on how well an artist tweets, rather than on whether they put on a good live show. Or rather, worrying over what the Twitter hordes thought of the show.
While social media has its uses - social media fan accounts indicate that the concept of belonging to a loyal tribe is still valid - there's nothing like a great album that could actually make an impact on somebody. Even if they are significantly fewer, there is evidence that there are fans who prefer full, cohesive albums to hit singles. More than creating earworms, for them it's about creating experiences.
Often over 30 and nostalgic, they like to have something to hold and look at, as well as to listen to. For them the album is still valid. The over-30 super fan buys to remember something they were there for. They want to say they were part of something huge or just part of something before everyone else was. It can mean a live show, or a moment in a band's career captured by an album.
This is Tarkan's demographic, and so his listeners still buy in to the format. It plays a part in Tarkan's continued selling momentum. For a Tarkan super fan, they are buying into a rollercoaster ride of highs and lows: The seismic shift from modest debut to sophomore superstar to an observed spiritual maturity after the dizzying heights of European fame. Or to the retrospective ruminations of what could have been on the road to global recognition. Tarkan's career is evidence, too, that nostalgia is a powerful selling tool.And like Tarkan, there is another anachronism in the music industry - the vinyl. Along with streaming sales, vinyl sales are also up. With downloads in sharp decline as consumers switch to streaming services, vinyl sales overtook digital downloads for the first time ever in 2016. Marking a big shift in music consumption, in the UK the Entertainment Retailers Association (ERA) said that around £2.4m was spent on vinyl from 25 November to 1 December, while digital downloads took in £2.1m for the record industry. In the same week in 2015, vinyl albums made £1.2m while digital ones made £4.4m.
Vinyl is generally more expensive than digital downloads, which accounts for its bigger share of album sales, which means that downloads are still the more popular product. According to the ERA, 120,000 vinyl albums were sold in November 2016, compared with 295,000 digital ones. Although it still represents less than 2% of the overall music market, nonetheless, the "vinyl revival" has been one of the most surprising success stories of the digital music era.
The Tangible Vibe of Vinyl

The interest in vinyl is one that many wouldn't have anticipated after the CD was introduced in the 1980s and decades later, digital music and streaming services. Not so long ago the digital download was meant to be the future. Few would have predicted that an album format, first invented in 1948 and based on stamping a groove into a piece of plastic, would be outselling it in 2016. The emergence of new technologies in media, however, has seemed to amplify our interest in pop-culture anachronisms.
As with the US and the UK, vinyl sales have seen a rise in the Turkish music industry. Turkish music has long had a love affair with vinyl and shellac, and old rare records can go for high amounts of money. British label Finders Keepers Records most successful vinyl albums in 2009 were two re-issues of 70s era Turkish records, while for some tourists, a visit to a vinyl record store in Istanbul can sometimes be a defining moment.
Best selling Turkish albums often get a vinyl release. Tarkan's 2016 tribute album to Turkish music's century old past was released in vinyl four months after its CD release, and there are plans for his 2017 pop album to get a vinyl release. Tarkan's back catalogue has also been released in vinyl. Super fans prefer them over CDs. They invest in his records as a mementos, but it's also a show of loyalty.
In April 2016, a BBC/ICM poll found that people who listened to music on streaming services were more likely to buy vinyl - often as a goodwill gesture to an artist they loved. The trend towards streaming has led people back to vinyl as a way of tangibly owning music, and because streaming encouraged music discovery. Another key driver in the trend for returning to tangible music recently has been the deaths of some music world giants, which helped vinyl sales go up. After David Bowie’s death, he became the bestselling vinyl artist of 2016, with five albums posthumously featuring in the top 30.This boost in vinyl sales is part of a wider shift in the fortunes of the music industry back towards turning a profit again - at least in the Anglosphere. In December, one of the big three global record labels, Warner Music, reported their best profits in eight years, of which $1bn came directly from streaming, and in the first half of 2016, streaming revenue in the US grew by 57% to $1.6bn. In contrast, CD sales were down 10% on last year.
This year Sony Music, another of the big three, said it will start pressing its own vinyl releases again for the first time since 1989. Streaming may have killed the CD, but its flow to vinyl has seemingly breathed life into record stores. It was thought that with streaming the music scene would become a crime scene to the slaughter of the record store, because millennials would just stream and be digital. But increasingly young people are showing they still want something tangible and real.
That is where vinyl is taking on the role that the CD used to have for over-25s. Vinyl's survival from the threat of extinction proves that younger generations are interested in tanigible music - even if as a token gesture. In the BBC/ICM poll, 48% of those surveyed said they did not play the vinyl they bought - while 7% did not even own a turntable.
For some, familiarity breeds contempt; the CD has been viewed as the lowest common denominator for bargain bucket music. It can be mass produced at home, duplicating equipment is readily available, and doesn't benefit from the nostalgic commodity of the cassette, while vinyl is this mystical thing from the past. Vinyl needs care. You need to protect it from the elements, and let it age gracefully enough to pass it down to a loved one. A CD doesn't have the same vibe.
Tangible music becomes important all the more for a generation who grows up with technology overkill, because maturity breeds nostalgia, even if it's not their own. A record is not just valid for a certain generation, but any generation when it reaches a certain age. Each new generation, as it gets older, reaches for their greatest hits to the scratchy soundtrack of their lives. Touch evokes memories and experiences that add to the music. They discover they want to hold that soundtrack in their hands, and not have it in some cloud.
Even if it is a fad, and even if it passes, what this shows us is that music fans have an inherent hunger for a tangible manifestation of their music taste. They want something they can touch, show and feel which describes who they are. What vinyl shows, too, is the unpredictability of the industry. So, record sales are over. But there's always the chance of a comeback.
The making of music doesn't end, it just changes. The role of music in an artist's career will always be central, but then, so is reinvention. If you're not selling physical copies of music, you've got to be selling something else. Vinyl is evidence there are other areas of income out there. They just need to be found.
Back to Main | Part 1 | End of Part 2 | Part 3

















<< Back to Main Page