Manifesto Translations Prose & Poetry Letters to B Musings Words Culture & Music Other Works Copyright
Official Site Q & A Biography Discography Concert Reports Magazine Reports Articles News Reports News Videos Pictures Pick of the Day Links

Wednesday, October 11, 2017

Pop Culture Kills

Article by Mark Mayhey reporting from London, UK

In the first two parts of this mini-serial, the aural autopsy of the music industry and its global actors revealed a serial killer. One whose MO is murder on the dancefloor and a high body count, because, as Mark Mahey explains, pop, by its very nature, kills.

When we talk about popular culture, and its idols and its casualties, the word "pop" - standing alone or in front of "culture", "music", "life" - overflows with meanings that can unite or polarise us. It's been said pop is above all an abbreviation of popular culture: made for everyone. It can also be an attitude that floats between high culture and mass culture. But, from art to culture, from music to life, what pop is really is change. When it's no longer relevant it will kill its traditional manifestations: We have seen digitisation kill off the traditional mass culture industries – music, movies, media, books, television – only for pop to give rise to the individual customisation of culture.

In a February 2010 interview with The New York Times, the novelist and Generation-X theorist Douglas Coupland argued that Harry Potter, Taylor Swift and Avatar are not great cultural mega­trends like disco, which involved absolutely everyone in the culture. Now, everyone basically is their own microculture, their own nanoculture, their own generation. Therefore it's hard to still speak of a common culture, if the most popular element of pop is individual taste and creativity.

Pop seems increasingly to be more like love: personal, idiosyncratic and a little bit blind. Somewhat like Tarkan acolytes, for whom the studio and the stage are still the temples where the magic comes to life. The artist is clearly a studio junkie, and when he shifts off his mortal coil, one wants to imagine his pop heaven would be a big studio in the sky. Filled with sun and sun dappled cloud-shaped gazelles serenely dipping their snouts in limpid pools of blue, while birds sing sweetly above.

But studio junkie or not, you wouldn't know it from his album output. Ten albums in twenty-five years is a zen-like rumination on mastering music and Tarkan's perfectionism when it comes to the final cuts of his songs. In the studio owned and operated by his longtime producer, you wonder what role the engineer inhabits. Is he simply a "yes" man, or someone who has serious input into the Tarkan sound. You wonder about the songs that never made the grade. You wonder, because that's the fabric of intimacy his vocal interpretations rely on.

And the one-on-one intimacy Tarkan exudes to his fans has always extended from studio to the stage - a trend major artists are picking up on as pop today increasingly demands intimacy over spectacle. Twenty-seven years ago, Madonna set the template for modern pop concerts with her Blond Ambition world tour. From its hydraulic stage to Jean-Paul Gaultier's iconic costumes, it raised the bar for stadium-sized spectacle. Now, after seven huge world tours, the star is to "reinvent" pop tours into smaller-scale shows where she can talk directly to the audience.

Madonna isn't channelling Tarkan, but she might as well be: This is his form of intimacy; for over a decade he has been calling the faithful to his side at his Harbiye shows, packing the open air arena night after night. Tarkan's talent might be undisputed to some, a matter of taste for others, but he is a pop icon. The Happy Meal bonus is the fact that it's attached to someone down-to-earth. He is one of us; he cares about the things we care about.

He is that rare breed. He is an artist with integrity. Not just his kindness and decency, it's his softness, sensuality, and playfulness - once the object of ridicule in his youth - which sets him apart and makes him feel pertinent to our times. And it's why any forced musical machismo grates on the senses like a musical mis-step. Tarkan is a breath of fresh air in an age where popular culture is trying to free itself from infantile patriarchy.

In this post-Trump era, male predatory behaviour is everywhere. In the film industry, sexual allegations against Harvey Weinstein, who helped define popular culture and presented himself as a liberal lion, a champion of women and a winner of not just artistic but humanitarian awards, reveals that it's not too soon to conclude his behaviour over the course of a storied career has, at times, been disgusting towards women.

It's no wonder women find the cult of Tarkan so alluring, when his signature sensitivity feels like a welcome blip on the popular landscape. In an increasingly dark world, Tarkan is an antidote, not because he is above it, but because he has survived it. His voice tells us he knows, he cares, and we are not alone. It's this genuine decency and talent that simultaneously makes Tarkan the greatest popstar the world will never know.

Let's Talk About Pop, Baby

When we talk about pop music, we're not just talking about music. When we talk about the end of the Turkish music industry, it's in terms of album sales, not in terms of music. Pop is an industry; success equates with money. We have to talk about figures; its success must be a measurable amount because pop music within popular culture is still about mass movements of some kind. Digitisation has converted it into the popular trends of big data going viral. It's about chart numbers, viewing hits and ad revenue. A pop song's success is not in its artistic merit, but in its materialistic mojo, quantified by quantity, not quality.

However, where some achievements can be measured in Nielsen points and some neatly summarised on a sales chart, ordinary benchmarks can't be used to measure artistry. So, how do we measure success? Sales and recognition are only roughly correlated. Arcade Fire, a Canadian indie-rock group, has been nominated for numerous Grammys, won a Grammy, racked up Brit awards and Juno awards, and performed in New York's Central Park with David Bowie and at huge festivals like Coachella: all benchmarks of critical success. Yet their top-selling album "The Suburbs" sold 765,000 copies in America and only 343,000 in Britain.

This is the dilemma pop music creates when you want sales and the critical recognition. You want both the music and the money. The two driving forces of a pop artist's psyche is the desire for fame and success, with a genuine artist working hard beneath that drive. The Turkish music industry is discovering serious artists, but the more successful they become, the more they are reduced to tweeting out music station chart listings to document success. And when you sell your artistic integrity to gain the recognition of the masses, you become the captive of your celebrity. It's a golden rat trap, where you have to pay for success as well as achieve it.

Artists like Tarkan will have suffered this dichotomy. Possibly it's how his 2001 album "Karma" came about; it was a musical curveball after his European hit "Şımarık" from his 1997 "Ölürüm Sana". From Europop to ethno-art and back again, every album since has been a struggle to find the balance between current commerciality and a calibre of music that is timeless. And for Turkish pop that struggle is real: Tarkan's long term producer has tweeted that Turkish pop is in its worst era ever, while Tarkan's boss - with nearly half of the Turkish music industry's pop icons in his mausoleum - has complained that companies need to sponsor music artists instead of sport personalties for a better investment.

Having two of the kingpins of Turkish pop publicly tweet these harsh realities is a devastating testament to the end of what was a billion dollar industry. It's also proof that social media not only allows us to grieve together and rediscover meaningful moments, it's a chain that has a heavy ball at the end of it. The contagion of social media now means pop culture is in real time; more brash, more vivid, with more blood to spill in homage to the bitch goddess of success.

It's one reason why streaming works so well; figures are crunched out in real time. Keep an ear out to its big data, and multiple trends in contemporary pop music make themselves known. Globalisation. Multi-artist collaborations. Slower tempos. And yet it might tell us the most about its related subject: How hits are made now that streaming is the way most of the world listens to music.

In uncovering the way streaming is changing the sound of pop, Pitchfork's Marc Hogan summarises in a paragraph how throughout the history of recorded music, formats have helped shape what we hear.

"Our ideas about how long a single should be date back to what could fit on a 45 RPM 7" vinyl record. AM radio meant mono recordings, rather than stereo, and producer Phil Spector’s Wall of Sound - with its cavernous echo and massed instruments - was built for it, offering plenty of depth through a single speaker. Video killed the radio star. Ringtones birthed the quick-hit digital chirps of snap music. The requirements for American Top 40 FM radio, in particular, grew so byzantine by the early 2010s, when blaring, mathematically precise hits reigned supreme, that an industrial-strength supply chain of super-producers and songwriters emerged to fulfill them."

Now, according to Hogan and the experts he brainpicked, it's possible to write songs "right" and "wrong" for streaming, and no aspect of a song, from production to vocal performance, is unaffected by the regime change. Hit-making songwriters and producers are tailoring tracks to fit a musical landscape of imagined desires dominated by streaming.

The dying art of the great song intro is attritubted to this domination - that's the view of producer Mark Ralph who co-produced two Clean Bandit number ones this year, and it's backed up by stats. The average intro time has dropped from more than 20 seconds to five seconds since the mid-1980s, research has found. Great song intros, where a tune builds up before the vocal kicks in, are becoming an endangered species as fickle music fans skip tracks if they don't get immediate gratification.

This means new songwriting trends emerge. They grow popular, play themselves out, and are devoured, Alien-like, by the opposing styles that were lurking inside of them all along. It even has its own subgenre: Trash pop consists of catchy, but shallow lyrics, synthetic instrumentals and autotune galore. It became extremely popular and mainstream in the mid to late 2000s - before streaming was even a twinkle in Spotify's eye - through the early 2010s, with legitimate popstars devoting themselves entirely to the genre, as well as a plethora of reality TV stars and internet sensations foraying into the subgenre.

Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Pop

Although it has gained more recent popularity, trash pop has always been around in some form as a middle-finger to "high" art. Its past mass movements were one of the things going for it; it recognised the common denominator. In white European history, popular culture is characteristic of the "less-educated" social classes, such as the barbarians, the Philistines, and hoi polloi (the masses) - words originated for non-whites (and at one time seen as sub-human). Throughout modern history, when pop was frowned upon, it was because it was seen as an attack not only on the refined senses, but on the privileged establishment it usually parodied.

As a result of this discrimination against pop, examples of critical recognition (or lack thereof) failing to act as a barometer to artistry litter the annals of creativity. Black artist Jean-Michel Basquiat is a darling of pop culture, but not museums. His art is the most expensive work by a US artist ever sold at auction, yet America's museums snub him. There is no public monument to him, no institution named after him and New York City has preserved none of his famous graffiti.

In an effort to "white-wash" music this time, one of Elvis Presley's best selling LPs, "Elvis's Christmas Album" is legendary. At the time of the first album's original release, "White Christmas" composer Irving Berlin was so offended by Elvis's Motown rendition that he is rumoured to have written to major radio stations asking them not to play it.

And corporate censorship was an issue for writer Rod Serling, who was often forced to change his scripts after TV sponsors read them and found something they felt was too controversial. The most famous of these was when Serling was going to attack white privilege in "A Town Has Turned to Dust", which was based on the case of Emmett Till, a black teenager tortured and murdered by a group of white thugs in 1955 Mississippi. "By the time the censors had gotten to it, my script had turned to dust," Serling later commented.

Serling found his "middle finger" to elitism in the TV series the "Twilight Zone", however, avoiding censorship by turning social commentary into science-fiction subtext. It bridged pulp fiction with the metaphysical, and showcased pop culture as a great equaliser, albeit a chaotic whiteboard where one threw things at it to see what would stick.

On its experimental fringe, the TV series' wilful perversion and trashy delights mark a collision point between pop culture indulgence and parodic excess, but Serling and his artistic integrity was the glue that gave it a cohesive whole. He kept the show focused on the human heart and compassion and alienation - all of which were common issues in his era and are equally common now. That's why it endures, not because of the gimmicky, twist endings. On the other hand, trash pop is catchy, generic, and ultimately throwaway - especially the music side. And that's the point. There's no pressure of prestige; it's simply having fun. But it's no fun if you're dancing alone.

If there is no artistic integrity, then there needs to be some form of integrity to hold it together. This is often based on how popular it is - but the more popularity it gains, the more it comes within an atmosphere of conformity within the medium's mainstream. If the mainstream dumbs down elite artistic movements, it also tames trashy ones. It goes for all forms of pop culture - music, books or TV. For all the attention-grabbing hypersexualisation of "tits and ass", with success the medium will start to take itself seriously. Think the later seasons of "Game of Thrones". But for all efforts, it's still cannon fodder for Internet memes and gifs. That's its goal, but ultimately its gaol.

Not all pop is trash, but all trash is pop. Some of the trash is awaiting future appreciation and cult status; some is just trash. As for which pop is for downtime, and which for all time, only time will tell. For example, the explosion in streaming has helped the music industry return to growth after more than a decade of piracy and plummeting profits, but the music that's being played is not creating opportunities to discover the next Adele or Whitney Houston. Where even a 30 second sample on Spotify may become an artform, to encourage more than one-hit wonders and keep alive the principle of buying an album, one needs to realise that time is trash disposal.

Time is needed because art is ageless, or ages well. Trash rots. It doesn't stand the test of time. It's a throwaway mass of consumptive faeces that will fossilise or digitally degrade over time to be only of interest to archaeologists on how we used to live. When Rob Lowe talks about Playboy Hugh Hefner's recent death, he talks about the pop landscape of his generation with the awe of an archaeologist lecturing on the pharaohs of ancient Egypt.

Lowe, once the crown prince of the bad boys and a legendary party animal until an infamous sex tape with underage girls surfaced in the eighties, sugarcoats Hefner - there have been constant reminders of his support for civil rights, his opposition to racism, his bold stand against puritan America - but the way Hefner's pop defines women is appalling. As Hollywood Reporter's Stephen Galloway says, no matter how much one might like to romanticise him, his legacy is this: sexism, stereotyping and objectification. The young men who were unable to break free from Playboy's insidious thinking ultimately saw their pop culture icon age into a vulnerable old man who couldn't break from his past.

The Cult in Pop Culture

In this vein, Lowe's eulogy is not for Hefner, but the era of Hefner - of a "time before everyone had a mobile phone with a camera attached, before the internet and Facebook and a culture where everyone simply has to post every photo of every party they attend". An era dies, but pop survives, because pop is change. Pop is now. And "now" - as Lowe attests - is a concept that quickly leaves you behind. Lowe's "now" was a totally different era in terms of what was valued, and Playboy was sometimes your only shot at fame. Now, if you're willing to eat bugs or throw a chair at your best friend or mother, you can star in a reality TV series. Internet porn killed the Bunny girl. YouTubers killed the Hollywood celebrity.

And so it goes: The Beatles killed Elvis Presley. Michael Jackson killed the Beatles. Rap killed the pop star. It's the nature of the beast. Pop survives because pop isn't squeamish; it kills its darlings. Like all things chained to the ups and downs of popularity, it has to make space for the next "in" thing, so it's destined to kill the thing it loves. But it's a cult that kills and ressurects its royalty after a time, because the best is always recycled. Passing time adds antiquity and longevity to validate it as more that just the passing popular fancy of a dead era.

When a downward-spiralling Elvis died 40 years ago on 16 August 1977, a cynical music industry insider was overheard to remark that it was a "smart career move". Apocryphal tale or not, death has given a lucrative boost to the selling power of not just Elvis, but also Bob Marley, Jimi Hendrix, Prince, David Bowie and a host of other music legends. Elvis's legacy and monetary worth remain immensely strong in particular - according to Forbes' list of top earning dead stars he earned $27m (£21m) in 2016, and sold one million albums.

It's not against nature to want a favourable critical or commercial reaction, but success doesn't always recognise quality. The recent Blade Runner sequel, 2049, is set to shift the way film studios treat past box office failures. It no longer matters if a given movie was a box-office dud when it first emerged, for there’s every chance it will still emerge as a cultural touchstone, albeit if one is prepared to hang on a mere 35 years for society to catch up.

A sequence involving Harrison Ford's Deckard in the Blade Runner sequel is very telling; a confrontation with Ryan Gosling's character in a forsaken Vegas concert hall is overlooked by flickering projections of Marilyn Monroe, Elvis and Liberace, giving a dazzlingly spooky thanatotic charge and a reminder that our relationship with cultural icons run deep. The sociologists say that musicians like Elvis become "intimate strangers" who feel like family. We may have been following them for decades, grown up with them. When they die, we mourn as if we knew them, because they have been part of our lives.

It's called classical conditioning: Singers are connected deeply to our emotional life, and the popular music that tends to mean the most to us is the music of our youth. That's the time of our romantic and sexual awakening, so singers become part of our coming of age. Then the singer dies, and all of a sudden, those memories come flooding back. Likewise, the way to explore a nation's identity is through a country's music, its singers and the intimate connection they establish with their fans.

Martin Stokes, a lecturer in Ethnomusicology at Oxford University and the writer of "The Republic of Love: Cultural Intimacy in Turkish Popular Music" advocates this thinking. At the heart of Stokes' 2010 book are the voices of three musicians - gay nightclub and classical Turkish music star Zeki Müren, arabesk originator Orhan Gencebay, and pop diva Sezen Aksu - who collectively have dominated mass media in Turkey since the early 1950s. The dissection of Turkey's recent history and its conflicting national identities through these three musicians reveal the conflicting dynamics between state ideology and pop culture, analysed within the frustration of sexual identities, chaotic urbanisation, and evolution.

In today's perceived slide towards political Islamic populism, Turkey often looks back to Tarkan and a fairytale version of the nineties as an example of a more open and permissive society. But Tarkan's domination symbolises more: He is the three artists of Stokes' book rolled into one. Tarkan speaks to the sexually confused, the disenfranchised and the rebellious fringe, because he has at one time or another been through it. If the dark legends circulating his young life are to believed, his rise to fame truly is a Hollywood rags to riches inspirational tale.

From being bullied by racist Germans and alienated by conservative Turks, Tarkan was always the outsider. A victim of domestic abuse with "father issues", when Tarkan speaks out for women, animals and the environment, he speaks from experience. It's the injured child inside of him who sings to us about the love that leads you out to the other side. The best of his music is forged from such energy, and it's why his vocal performances touch the popular core.

However, the terrible twist to the end of the tale is one that Serling would appreciate: The industry Tarkan has almost single-handedly carried for decades is dying because of him. For Turkish pop to survive it needs to kill its most beloved son, before he kills it. For all his importance to scholarly speculation on his impact on culture and his pivotal role in the workplace of Turkish pop music, Tarkan is a pop artist in a dying industry - the crowned king to a doomed world.

Back to Main | Part 1 | Part 2 | End of Part 3

<< Week 16 Chart Update | Tarkan News Index | Week 17 Chart Update >>

Creative Commons License

© CC License 2004-24. Unless otherwise stated all poetry, prose and art are the original work of the blog owner.